What to do If you fall out with a 50/50 business partner in a Limited Liability Company?
Sharing ownership of a Limited Liability Company (SL) equally may seem like a good idea at first when setting up an SL: shared decisions, equal effort, and a common vision. However, when serious disagreements arise between partners, the lack of a majority can lead to a corporate deadlock that paralyzes the company. From our business consultancy in Palma de Mallorca, we have supported many entrepreneurs in these kinds of situations and know how hard it can be to stay objective when conflicts become personal.
What options are available to resolve the conflict?
1. Direct negotiation: talk before breaking
The first route should always be dialogue. Reviewing the company’s bylaws and any signed shareholders’ agreement together can reveal pre-established solutions. Often, a good coffee and a structured conversation are more effective than any legal procedure.
2. Mediation or arbitration: impartial solutions
If reaching an agreement on your own is not possible, business mediation can be extremely helpful. An impartial mediator can guide both parties toward a consensual solution without needing to go to court. Arbitration, on the other hand, resolves the conflict through a binding award. Both options are faster, less costly, and less stressful than court proceedings.
3. One partner exits
When disagreement is irreconcilable, one partner buying out the other’s shares or selling to a third party may be considered. Mechanisms like the Andorran clause or the Texas shoot-out can facilitate this exit if previously agreed. Otherwise, an objective share valuation and clear sale terms can be negotiated.
4. Legal action: last resort
If all previous routes fail, court action remains an option. A judge may intervene in cases of contested decisions or even order the company’s dissolution if the conflict is structural. However, this option involves high costs, long delays, and a major deterioration of the business relationship.
When is it advisable to hire a mediator?
In our experience as a consultancy, we recommend seeking guidance from a lawyer in Palma specialized in corporate disputes. We strongly recommend mediation in cases of 50/50 partner disputes. The reasons are many:
- Impartiality: the mediator does not represent either party.
- Speed: agreements can be reached in just a few sessions.
- Confidentiality: protects the company’s reputation.
- Consensual solutions: agreements are more sustainable.
- Preserves the relationship: essential if continuing the partnership is desired.
Additionally, Law 5/2012 supports this procedure in commercial matters, providing legal security to any resolution reached.
Summary of alternatives
| Solution | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Direct negotiation | Fast, preserves relationship | Not always feasible if conflict is deep |
| Mediation or arbitration | Less costly and neutral | Requires both parties’ cooperation |
| Partner exit | Resolves the deadlock | Negotiating terms may be difficult |
| Legal action | Definitive legal solution | Slow, costly, and damaging |
| Dissolution | Ends the conflict | Company shuts down |
Conclusion
When 50/50 partners in an SL come into conflict, it is essential to act strategically, patiently, and with specialized legal advice. At our business consultancy in Palma de Mallorca, we are ready to help you analyze your situation and guide you toward the most effective option, protecting your investment and your company’s viability. If you’re considering creating an SL in Palma de Mallorca, contact us for support from professionals in mediation, commercial law, and corporate management.
What to do If you fall out with a 50/50 business partner in a Limited Liability Company?
Sharing ownership of a Limited Liability Company (SL) equally may seem like a good idea at first when setting up an SL: shared decisions, equal effort, and a common vision. However, when serious disagreements arise between partners, the lack of a majority can lead to a corporate deadlock that paralyzes the company. From our business consultancy in Palma de Mallorca, we have supported many entrepreneurs in these kinds of situations and know how hard it can be to stay objective when conflicts become personal.
What options are available to resolve the conflict?
1. Direct negotiation: talk before breaking
The first route should always be dialogue. Reviewing the company’s bylaws and any signed shareholders’ agreement together can reveal pre-established solutions. Often, a good coffee and a structured conversation are more effective than any legal procedure.
2. Mediation or arbitration: impartial solutions
If reaching an agreement on your own is not possible, business mediation can be extremely helpful. An impartial mediator can guide both parties toward a consensual solution without needing to go to court. Arbitration, on the other hand, resolves the conflict through a binding award. Both options are faster, less costly, and less stressful than court proceedings.
3. One partner exits
When disagreement is irreconcilable, one partner buying out the other’s shares or selling to a third party may be considered. Mechanisms like the Andorran clause or the Texas shoot-out can facilitate this exit if previously agreed. Otherwise, an objective share valuation and clear sale terms can be negotiated.
4. Legal action: last resort
If all previous routes fail, court action remains an option. A judge may intervene in cases of contested decisions or even order the company’s dissolution if the conflict is structural. However, this option involves high costs, long delays, and a major deterioration of the business relationship.
When is it advisable to hire a mediator?
In our experience as a consultancy, we recommend seeking guidance from a lawyer in Palma specialized in corporate disputes. We strongly recommend mediation in cases of 50/50 partner disputes. The reasons are many:
- Impartiality: the mediator does not represent either party.
- Speed: agreements can be reached in just a few sessions.
- Confidentiality: protects the company’s reputation.
- Consensual solutions: agreements are more sustainable.
- Preserves the relationship: essential if continuing the partnership is desired.
Additionally, Law 5/2012 supports this procedure in commercial matters, providing legal security to any resolution reached.
Summary of alternatives
| Solution | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Direct negotiation | Fast, preserves relationship | Not always feasible if conflict is deep |
| Mediation or arbitration | Less costly and neutral | Requires both parties’ cooperation |
| Partner exit | Resolves the deadlock | Negotiating terms may be difficult |
| Legal action | Definitive legal solution | Slow, costly, and damaging |
| Dissolution | Ends the conflict | Company shuts down |
Conclusion
When 50/50 partners in an SL come into conflict, it is essential to act strategically, patiently, and with specialized legal advice. At our business consultancy in Palma de Mallorca, we are ready to help you analyze your situation and guide you toward the most effective option, protecting your investment and your company’s viability. If you’re considering creating an SL in Palma de Mallorca, contact us for support from professionals in mediation, commercial law, and corporate management.
Gestoría en Palma de Mallorca.
Si buscas una gestoría cerca de ti, asesoramos a empresas en el ámbito laboral, fiscal y contable. También somos una gestoría administrativa en Palma y realizamos traspasos de vehículos.
